Name: Peeps Easter Pudding Cups Recipe
Prep time: 15 min
Total time: 1 h 15 min
Yield: 10
Ingredients: 1 5.9 ounce package instant chocolate pudding; 2 cups cold milk; 8 ounces frozen whipped topping, thawed; 10 Oreos, crushed; Easter sprinkles; 10 bunny Peeps; 30 chocolate eggs; 10 Sweet Tart Ropes

Jump to Recipe

Who else loves festive desserts that are easy to make? This Peeps Easter Pudding Cups Recipe will be a hit! With bright colors and a sweet twist, your kids will adore it. Plus, it’s perfect for busy schedules or last-minute treats. Gather your simple ingredients, and the rest is a breeze, I promise!

I love Easter desserts that are simple. Sweet treats like these bring smiles to everyone. Plus, there are so many ways to customize them. Use your favorite candies, sprinkles, or other flavors to add your personal touch. This one does not disappoint.

You’ll spend less time baking and more time enjoying with your family. A simple process makes it a breeze for even the busiest parents. The best part? Kids can join in and help assemble! Memories and yummy desserts all in one? That’s a win-win for any mom.

Easy Easter Dessert Recipes

With these delightful Easter treats, there’s something for everyone to enjoy, whether you’re baking with the kids or whipping up a dessert spread to impress. Each recipe is as charming as it is easy to make, making your Easter celebration feel extra special and full of joy.

All of these are show stopping and are sure to bring giggles to the table and to your sweet Easter celebration.

Ingredients Needed To Easter Pudding Cups Using Peeps

To make the cutest layered delight, you just need a few fun and colorful ingredients! Each one adds its own special touch to this cheerful dessert. Whether it’s chocolatey goodness, festive decorations, or adorable Peeps, everything comes together perfectly to create a treat that’s as much fun to make as it is to eat.

Ingredients and Why They’re Important

instant chocolate pudding
The base of our dessert! This gives it that rich, chocolatey flavor everyone loves and holds the layers together beautifully.
cold milk
Essential to whip up the pudding. It blends smoothly and gives you that creamy consistency.
frozen whipped topping, thawed
Perfect for fluffy layers! It balances the richness of the chocolate and adds a light, airy texture.
Oreos
These crushed cookies mimic “dirt” for a playful twist. Plus, they add a delicious crunch to every bite.
Easter sprinkles
Bring on the fun and color! These add a festive pop that makes the dessert extra special for the occasion.
bunny Peeps
The stars of the show! They add a charming touch and sweetness, making each cup irresistible.
chocolate eggs
These represent the “hidden treasures” of Easter. They’re not only decorative but also a tasty treat!
Sweet Tart ropes
Great for creating “handles” or fun shapes for decoration. They add a tangy kick to balance the sweetness.

Why These Ingredients Make the Best Dessert

Together, these ingredients create a dessert that’s more than just food; it’s a memory in the making! The creamy layers, crunchy Oreos, and whipped topping create a delicious mix of textures. Add the colorful sprinkles, chocolate eggs, and bunny Peeps, and you’ve got a treat that’ll make every kid (and adult) grin from ear to ear. Plus, the mason jars keep everything neat and adorable. It’s simple, festive, and packed with flavor—what more could you ask for?

Dietary Modifications for Homemade Pudding Cups

If you or someone in your family has dietary restrictions, don’t worry! You can still enjoy these festive dessert cups with a few simple swaps. Here are some ideas to make this recipe gluten-free, dairy-free, or even vegan while keeping it just as adorable and delicious!

Gluten-Free Alternatives:

Instant Chocolate Pudding: Check for a gluten-free mix. Many well-known brands now offer gluten-free options, so it’s easy to find!
Oreos: Use gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies instead of regular Oreos. They taste just as good and still give that fun “dirt” look.
Easter Sprinkles: Not all sprinkles are gluten-free, so double-check the label or grab a brand that’s safe for gluten-free diets.

Dairy-Free Alternatives:

Chocolate Pudding: Opt for a dairy-free mix and make it with your favorite plant-based milk. Almond, oat, or coconut milk are great choices!
Whipped Topping: Use a dairy-free whipped topping, which is usually made with coconut or almond-based ingredients.
Chocolate Eggs: Look for dairy-free chocolate eggs, which are more common now in specialty or health food stores.
Peeps: Double-check Peeps ingredients, as some flavors might contain traces of dairy. If they’re not safe, use a fun, colorful dairy-free candy instead.

Vegan Options:

Chocolate Pudding: Choose a vegan mix, and mix it with plant-based milk like almond, soy, or oat.
Whipped Topping: Use a vegan whipped topping option. Coconut whipped cream works beautifully for this!
Cookies: Look for vegan chocolate cookies or use a homemade version to create the “dirt” layer.
Peeps Substitute: Since Peeps aren’t vegan (due to gelatin), try using small, colorful, vegan marshmallows or fruity gummy candies for decoration.
Chocolate Eggs: Swap for vegan chocolate eggs or even small, colorful candies to keep the festive touch.

Making these swaps doesn’t take away from the fun or flavor. The best part? Everyone can still join in to decorate and enjoy their dessert cups, no matter their dietary needs!

Tips for Making Homemade Pudding Cups

If you’ve never made anything like this at home before, it’s not hard at all. Here are some of my best tips for making it easily.

Prep Ingredients Ahead of Time
Save yourself time and stress by setting up an easy prep station. Have everything pre-measured and organized before you start layering. It’s a game-changer!
Choose the Right Containers
Small mason jars, clear plastic cups, or even fancy dessert glasses work perfectly. Clear containers show off those beautiful layers, making them look extra special.
Get Creative with Layers
Mix and match flavors for a fun twist! Chocolate, vanilla, or even butterscotch adds variety. You can also alternate cookie crumbs, crushed candy, or fresh fruit for extra pizzazz.
Make It a Fun Family Activity
Kids love decorating their own cups! Lay out bowls of toppings like sprinkles, candy, or mini marshmallows and let their imaginations run wild. Bonus points for bunny or Easter-themed decorations!
Add a Crunchy Surprise
Crushed cookies, granola, or pretzel bits add a surprise crunch to the creamy layers. It’s a simple touch that takes your treat cups to the next level.
Decorate the Containers
Tie a colorful ribbon around the jar or stick on Easter-themed stickers to make them extra cute. This little detail adds a festive vibe for any celebration.
Chill for Perfect Texture
Once assembled, pop the cups in the fridge for at least an hour. This helps the pudding set and keeps the toppings fresh, so everything tastes better when served.
Experiment with Themes
Don’t stop at Easter! You can customize dessert cups for birthday parties, sleepovers, or any holiday. Use colors or decorations that suit the occasion.
Set Up a Build-Your-Own Station
If you’re hosting, create a DIY pudding cup bar where guests can assemble their own. Lay out different flavors, toppings, and decorations—that way, everyone gets exactly what they want!
Make It Mess-Free
Use a piping bag (or a zip-top bag with the corner snipped) to neatly layer the creamy dessert into the cups. It’s easier, tidier, and gives a professional look.
Play with Toppings
Think outside the box with options like toasted coconut, mini chocolate chips, gummy candies, or fresh berries. These customizable toppings personalize each cup beautifully.
Label Each Cup
If you’re making multiple flavors or accommodating dietary restrictions, use small tags to label the cups. It’s a thoughtful detail that guests will appreciate.

Homemade treats like this are as easy or elaborate as you want them to be! From simple layers to detailed designs, they’re guaranteed to sweeten any celebration. Just have fun with it!

Peeps Alternatives for Decorating Easter Pudding Cups

Don’t worry if Peeps aren’t your thing or don’t fit your dietary needs! There are plenty of creative and festive options to decorate your dessert cups. These alternatives are just as colorful, fun, and easy to use, so no one will even miss the marshmallow bunnies.

Mini Marshmallows
Swap Peeps for mini marshmallows in pastel colors. They’re soft, sweet, and perfect for creating cute designs. Pro tip: arrange them in shapes like eggs or flowers for extra flair.
Chocolate Bunnies or Eggs
Add a touch of elegance (and chocolate) with small chocolate bunnies or foil-wrapped eggs. They’re festive and tasty, plus they double as a fun surprise once you dig into the cup!
Colorful Gummy Candies
Try bright, fruity gummies shaped like animals, eggs, or flowers. These are perfect for kids who love fruit flavors and add a chewy texture to balance the creamy pudding.
Fruity Candy Strips
Use rainbow-colored candy strips or ropes to create adorable “handles,” bows, or designs on top of your cups. They’re playful, tangy, and add a fun pop of color.
Fresh Fruit
Want to keep it healthier? Fresh berries like strawberries, raspberries, or blueberries make for beautiful and naturally sweet decorations. You can even cut kiwis or bananas into egg-like oval shapes!
Sugar Cookies
Top your cups with a mini sugar cookie decorated with frosting and sprinkles. You can bake them ahead of time and customize each one with festive designs.
Vegan Marshmallows
If you’re looking for a vegan option, try plant-based marshmallows. They’re just as fluffy and sweet as traditional ones but free of gelatin.
Edible Flower Decorations
For a unique and elegant twist, top your pudding cups with edible flowers like pansies or violas. They’ll make your dessert look like a springtime masterpiece!
Small Toy Decorations
If you’re not adding decorations to eat, use cute Easter-themed plastic picks or small toys like mini bunnies or chicks. Just remind guests to remove them before digging in!
Layered Jelly Shapes
Make gelatin in fun pastel colors, cut them into shapes like eggs or flowers, and add them as an edible topper. They’re wiggly, delightful, and oh-so-festive!

These Peeps alternatives will make your Easter pudding cups just as fun and customizable. Plus, they’re perfect for accommodating different preferences and needs. Get creative and have fun finding your favorite decoration combo!

How to Store and Serve Homemade Pudding Cups

To keep your creation fresh and delicious, store them in the fridge with lids or plastic wrap tightly covering the tops. You can make them up to a day in advance, giving you plenty of time to focus on other party prep. Don’t decorate them until the day of.

If you’re serving them at a gathering, consider displaying them on a tiered tray or a large platter for a pretty presentation. You could even tie ribbons around the cups or attach small name tags for a personalized touch. If you’re packing them to-go, use mason jars with secure lids to make them easy and mess-free for guests to enjoy later.

Keeping them cold until serving time ensures they stays creamy and the toppings stay fresh and vibrant. Little details go a long way in making your treats feel extra special!

Is Amazon a good option for buying Easter hosting needs?

Wide Selection: Amazon offers a vast range of products, from tableware and decorations to serving platters and themed party supplies. You can find everything from elegant dinnerware to fun, kid-friendly Easter-themed items in one place.

Convenience: Shopping on Amazon saves time, especially if you’re juggling multiple hosting tasks. With just a few clicks, you can have everything delivered to your doorstep, often within a couple of days if you’re a Prime member.

Customer Reviews: You can read reviews and ratings to ensure the quality of the products before purchasing, which is especially helpful for hosting essentials like table settings or decor.

Budget-Friendly Options: Amazon caters to a variety of budgets, offering both affordable and premium options. You can easily compare prices and find deals or bulk items for larger gatherings.

Last-Minute Solutions: If you’re running out of time, Amazon’s fast shipping can be a lifesaver for those last-minute hosting needs.

PeepsMarshmallow Bunnies and Chicks, 6 Packs of Chicks and Bunnies Candy 60 Count, Perfect for Party Favors and Spreading Joy During the Holiday Season, Ideal Easter Bunny Candy for Kids to Enjoy SweeTARTS Ropes, Tangy Strawberry, 5 oz Easter Cadbury Mini Rainbow Eggs (1 Pounds) 2 Bags of Cadbury Chocolate Eggs Each 8 oz, Cadbury Mini Eggs Perfect for Easter Celebrations, Treat Yourself to the Ultimate Chocolate Eggs Experience.Mystic Sprinkles Easter Sprinkle Mixes (Hop-A-Long Confetti Mix 2.6oz)Cottontail Sprinkle Mix| Made In USA By Sprinkle Pop| Lime Green White Sprinkles Mix With White Bunny Royal Icings And Pink Pastel| Easter Sprinkles For Decorating Cakes Cookie Cupcakes Ice Cream, 4oz Wide Mouth Mason Jar 8 oz – (4 Pack) – Kerr Wide Mouth Mason Jars With Airtight lids and Bands – For Canning, Fermenting, Pickling, Freezing – Glass jar, Microwave & Dishwasher Safe, Clear LaRibbons 3/8 Inch 100 Yards Grosgrain Ribbon Set 10 Yd/Roll 10 Rolls Striped and Polka Dot Spring Easter Craft Ribbon for Gift Wrapping Floral Bouquets Wedding Party Decoration cusugbaso Easter Tablecloth 60×84 Inch Rectangle – Easter Decorations for The Home – Water Resistant Spring Table Cloth Rectangle for Party,Table, Outdoor Decorations

Amazon is so convenient. It’s usually my first option and so easy to price check for the best prices.

Easter Treats for Kids

Before you head off, don’t miss these fun and festive recipes guaranteed to add a touch of sweetness to your Easter celebration. From kid-friendly snacks to eye-catching desserts that steal the show, there’s something perfect for every family gathering or holiday table.

These recipes will fill your holiday with joy and laughter, creating moments your family will treasure forever. Gather your loved ones, get creative in the kitchen, and make this Easter truly unforgettable!